Ministry Staff:
Rev. Timothy K. Hartzell, Lead Pastor
Casey Spencer, Assistant Pastor of Youth, Young Adults, and Groups
Heather Hartzell, Director of Children's Ministry

Kerri Girton, Director of Worship Arts

Leila Rotz, Director of Congregational Ministries

Robin Muffley, Director of Administrative Ministries

Support Staff:

Bob Rockwell, Church Custodian

Wayne Kinley, Church Accountant


Tim Hartzell

Rev. Timothy K. Hartzell, Lead Pastor

tim1faith@comcast.net

Pastor Tim grew up in the Lehigh Valley and graduated from United Wesleyan College in Allentown, PA, earning a bachelor’s degree in Bible and Theology with an emphasis in Sacred Music. While at college, he met Heather Crosser. They were married on July 20, 1985.

After graduation in 1986, Tim and Heather accepted their first pastoral ministry assignment at the Wesleyan church in Sandy Lake, Pa., where they would spend the next 11 years ministering to the youth and engaging in many other areas of church service and leadership. During this time, Tim also served as the president of the Western Pa. District Wesleyan Youth. Their sons, Reid and Ryan, were born in 1992 and 1995.  

In 1997, Tim and Heather accepted their next ministry assignment at Christ Wesleyan Church in Milton, Pa.  Tim’s initial role at the church was being the pastor to the new people, but grew to include men’s ministries and new-believer discipleship. It was an exciting time to serve on staff as the church grew from an average attendance of 600 to over 1,200 in just four years.   

In 2001, Tim and Heather accepted the call to be the pastoral family of Faith Wesleyan Church in Williamsport, Pa.  At that time, the church was struggling. Three pastoral transitions in the space of just three years had resulted in stressed relationships and frustration. Attendance had dwindled to an annual average of just 69. But within that number remained a faithful and committed group that were determined to reengage God’s mission. God honored their faithfulness.

In 2002, the church purchased the one-acre lot located on the north side of Maxwell Place. In 2003, the sanctuary was completely remodeled, a 32-car gravel parking lot was installed on the Maxell Property, and Pastor Tim and his family moved out of the parsonage and into their own home. A second worship service was added in 2004 as attendance grew to 163. In 2008, a major addition was added and by 2012, attendance had grown to 270. In 2014 and 2015, additional properties were added to the campus as the church prepares for future expansion.

In addition to leading the church, Pastor Tim enjoys going on adventures with Heather and his many hobbies which include hunting, fishing, trapping, backpacking, vegetable gardening, golf, playing his trumpet, wood cutting and carving with his chainsaw. He’s been a lifelong fan of the Pittsburgh Steelers, the New York Mets, and the Penn State Nittany Lions.   


Casey Spencer

Casey Spencer, Assistant Pastor of Youth, Young Adults and Groups

casey1faith@comcast.net

Pastor Casey is a graduate of Lycoming College, where he earned a bachelor’s in English Literature and Psychology. He spent more than seven years working in higher education, both as an admissions counselor and public relations officer, before joining the ministry team at Faith Wesleyan in 2013. 

An Assistant Pastor, Casey provides leadership to the youth and young adult ministries and small groups, as well as contributing to a variety of other areas in church. He also serves as District Youth President for the Penn-Jersey District of the Wesleyan Church. Casey earned an M.Div. degree from Indiana Wesleyan University in 2017.

He and his wife, Annie, live in Loyalsock with their two dogs, Nick and Harper. They love to cook and travel, and volunteer for both the collegiate and Greater Lycoming chapters of Habitat for Humanity. Casey loves to make and listen to music; you’ll often see him on percussion, piano or singing with the worship team. He also enjoys reading, exercise, the outdoors, a good cup of coffee and roaring campfire.


Heather Hartzell

Heather Hartzell, Director of Children's Ministry

heather1faith@comcast.net
Heather is a graduate of United Wesleyan College, where she earned a bachelor's degree in Elementary Education. She then continued her education at Lehigh University, earning a Master's degree in Elementary Education.
 
Active for many years in children's ministry, Heather has served as a Sunday School teacher, leader of a junior church program, and director of children's musicals. During their appointment at the Wesleyan Church in Sandy Lake, Pa., she assisted Pastor Tim in young adult, youth, and children's ministries.
 
In addition to serving in children and youth ministries, Heather's experience also includes more than 15 years of teaching in public schools. Prior to moving to Williamsport, she taught the sixth grade at Meadowbrook Christian School. Heather also served for five years as a teacher's aide and a long-time substitute in the Loyalsock School District.
 
Heather gives leadership to our Children's Sunday School, Sherman and Tucker's Place. She also provides leadership for Kid's Discipleship and Vacation Bible School.

Kerri Girton

Kerri Girton, Director of Worship Arts

kerri1faith@comcast.net

Kerri is a graduate from Ithaca College where she earned a Bachelor of Music with an outside field in Social Work. After graduating, she was a missionary in Bolivia for one year, then a Spanish and Music teacher at several schools in Delaware. Since moving back to Williamsport, Kerri has taught private piano & guitar lessons as well as preschool music and swimming classes.

As the Director of Worship Arts at Faith Wesleyan, Kerri directs the Celebration Choir, coordinates the worship teams and leads occasionally, oversees the projection and sound technicians and develops the weekly worship service order. She has a heart for helping people plug into the music ministry and loves to worship Jesus with her church family.

Kerri and her husband have two beautiful daughters and they are all very involved in the church life of Faith Wesleyan. She also enjoys running, finding new healthy recipes, learning to play the ukulele and exploring the outdoors in and around Williamsport. A perfect weekend consists of coffee, a Trader Joe's run and a hike in the woods.


Leila Rotz

Leila Rotz, Director of Congregational Ministries 

leila1faith@comcast.net

Leila is a graduate of Houghton College, where she earned a bachelor’s degree in Psychology with a minor in Education. After graduation, she worked as a therapeutic support staff person for Community Services Group, providing one-on-one support/interventions to several students. In 2011, Leila began serving on staff at Faith Wesleyan as Director of Congregational Ministries. In 2013, she married her husband, Reuben, and they reside in Nippenose Valley as they enjoy the country life!

Leila’s responsibilities include oversight of prayer requests and praises, encouragement/hospital/nursing home visits, and coordination of compassion responses consisting of meals and other helps for families in times of need.

Leila also gives leadership to our Children’s Registration/Security process as well as our Infant and Toddler Nurseries.

In Leila’s spare time she enjoys cooking, drinking coffee, and spending time with family and friends!


Robin Muffley


Robin Muffley, Director of Administrative Ministries

robin1faith@comcast.net

Robin graduated from the Williamsport School of Commerce with an Associate in Specialized Business degree.

Her prior experience includes seven years as office administrator at Center Manufacturing, and five years at Springs Window Fashions, where she worked as executive secretary to the director of operations. While at Springs, she served terms as president and secretary on the Springs of Achievement Team, which spearheaded fundraising, community and employee projects.

Robin serves in a wide range of administrative and technology capacities in support of the ministries of Faith Wesleyan. She especially enjoys writing feature articles for the religion section of the Williamsport Sun-Gazette and columns for the monthly church newsletter.

She is an avid reader, and an active member of the YMCA and Williamsport TOPS Chapter 1628. Robin and her husband, Charles, live in Williamsport with their devoted rescue cat, Babykat.